Saturday, November 25, 2017

Both Frames Moving Linearly...

And if both reference frames are moving,



From the post "Thought Experiment Gone Wrong" dated 17 Nov 2017,

\(x^{'}=\cfrac{x-vt}{\sqrt{1-v^2}}\)

So,

\(x^{''}=\cfrac{x^{'}-v^{'}t}{\sqrt{1-{v^{'}}^{2}}}\)

It is tempting to substitute one into the other, and get

\(x^{"}=\cfrac{\cfrac{x-vt}{\sqrt{1-v^2}}-v^{'}t}{\sqrt{1-{v^{'}}^{2}}}\)

in this case, \(v^{'}\) is the speed measured in \(x^{'}\) frame not \(x\).  Every unit in \(x^{'}\) as measured in \(x\) is scaled by the factor \(\cfrac{1}{\sqrt{1-v^2}}\).  Instead we should have,

\(x^{"}=\cfrac{{x-vt}-v^{'}t}{\sqrt{({1-v^2})(1-{v^{'}}^{2})}}=\cfrac{x-(v+v^{'})t}{\sqrt{({1-v^2})(1-{v^{'}}^{2})}}\)

where \(v^{'}\) is also scaled by \(\cfrac{1}{\sqrt{1-v^2}}\),

\(v^{'}\rightarrow \cfrac{v^{'}}{\sqrt{1-v^2}}\).

Do we scale \(v^{'}\) again in the denominator?  No.  The scaling factor from \(x^{"}\) to \(x^{'}\) does not get scaled again.  The translation term get scaled.

Just for the fun of it...