Wednesday, May 25, 2016

No Free Meal With Plasma

From the post "" dated

\(\cfrac{pV}{T_n}= -\cfrac{pV}{T}=ln(T^{ -A }_n)+C\)

\(C=(pV)_{\small{n=1}}\)

with \(T^{+}\),

\(\cfrac{pV}{T_p}= \cfrac{pV}{T}=ln(T^{ +A }_n)+C=-ln(T^{ -A }_n)+C\)  --- (*)

and

\(\cfrac{pV}{T_n}= -\cfrac{pV}{T}=-\cfrac{T^{+}}{\tau_o}.\cfrac{V}{A_o}\)

which is a constant.

with \(T^{+}\),

\(\cfrac{pV}{T_p}= \cfrac{pV}{T}=\cfrac{T^{+}}{\tau_o}.\cfrac{V}{A_o}\)

Both positive and negative temperature have the same equations, but does \(T^{+}\) does negative work?  No, a spinning \(T^{+}\) particles does not produce a \(g\) field that act against gravity, it does produce an \(E\) field.  Unless in the presence of an existing \(E\) field, \(T^{+}\) does not perform positive work.  \(T^{-}\) was removed from the system to decrease work done.  Adding \(T^{-}\) to the system will increase work done, and reduces temperature.  \(T^{-}\) itself does positive work against gravity.  So, equation

\(\Delta pV=-A\Delta T_{p}\)

is not valid! And so equation (*) for \(T^{+}\) is not valid.

We plot \(\cfrac{pV}{T}\) vs \(T\),  where \(T=T_{n}+T_{p}\),


Work done per temperature is a constant over temperature.  The increase in \(\cfrac{pV}{T}\) after \(T=1+T_{p}\) is due to the removal of \(\cfrac{T^{-}}{\tau_o}.\cfrac{V}{A_o}\) which is expected to act against \(\cfrac{T^{+}}{\tau_o}.\cfrac{V}{A_o}\).

This graph suggests that on cooling a hot gas by adding \(T^{-}\) particles, \(\cfrac{pV}{T}\) increases, but cooling by removing \(T^{+}\) particles, \(\cfrac{pV}{T}\) remains constant.

There is no free gain.  And removing negative temperature particles requires work.